Ahrefs and Semrush are among the most popular SEO tools on the market. Moz is also an alternative, but I prefer one of the first two. I was a loyal Semrush user from 2020, but have used Ahrefs as my main tool since 2025. After going through a solid four-figure number of keywords, I started to realise that Ahrefs rates a large share of keywords as easy to rank in the top 10 for. That made me curious...
What separates Ahrefs and Semrush, and how can you use them to improve your SEO work? I will look at two important aspects: how the platforms calculate Keyword Difficulty (KD), and why they show different search volumes for some keywords.
How do Ahrefs and Semrush calculate Keyword Difficulty?
Ahrefs:
Ahrefs calculates Keyword Difficulty based on the number of unique domains linking to the top 10 pages ranking for the keyword. In other words, the more strong links the top pages have, the higher the KD score. This makes Ahrefs a more link-focused tool, reflecting competition in terms of backlinks.
Semrush:
Semrush uses a combination of factors, including the authority of the pages ranking in the top results, the relevance of the content and the number of competitors targeting the same keyword. Semrush puts more weight on overall ranking factors, not just links.
Example: For the keyword "steakhouse Bergen", Semrush gives a Keyword Difficulty of 31% (medium), while Ahrefs rates it at just 3 (very easy). This large difference shows how different calculation methods can produce very different results, which underlines the importance of reading the data critically. Also note the difference in search volume in the images below.


Why are there big differences in search volume?
Another noticeable difference between Ahrefs and Semrush is how they report search volume. This comes down to different access to, and use of, data sources.
Ahrefs relies mainly on data from Google Keyword Planner, supplemented with its own clickstream data to estimate search trends and click-through rates. Semrush, on the other hand, gathers data from a wider range of sources, including Google Ads, and estimates search volume with its own model.
This can lead to significant discrepancies, especially for niche keywords or keywords with a strong local focus, such as "steakhouse Bergen". For example, Semrush may show a much higher search volume than Ahrefs for certain terms because the platforms interpret the data differently. That brings us to the main point of this article.
Which platform is best?
The answer depends on your needs and personal preference.
Choose Ahrefs if
- You focus a lot on backlinks and want a thorough analysis of link profiles.
- You want a simple and intuitive interface.
Choose Semrush if
- You want an all-in-one tool with extensive analysis of paid search, technical SEO and competition.
- You want deeper insight into search volumes and competitive factors.
My conclusion is that both Ahrefs and Semrush are invaluable tools in day-to-day SEO work, but it is important to remember that the numbers they give are not absolute. As shown above, Semrush often rates keywords as harder than they actually are, and shows higher search volume where it has a broader data basis. These are estimates, not exact numbers, and that is worth keeping in mind, while still using the data for what it is worth.
My advice is therefore to use these tools as guidance, not as the final answer. If your company has the budget, combine insight from both platforms with your own experience to build a more precise strategy. I will stick with Ahrefs for now, but may switch to Semrush if I need better data for competitor analysis and paid activity. In the end, your own judgement should carry the most weight.
Other SEO tools worth knowing
Good tools make SEO work easier. Here are some useful ones:
- PageSpeed Insights:
- A tool from Google that analyses the speed of your website. Faster websites give a better user experience and better rankings.
- Google Search Console:
- Helps you monitor how your website performs in Google. For example, you can check whether your pages are indexed correctly and identify errors that prevent ranking.
- Ahrefs:
- An advanced SEO tool for analysing competitors, finding keywords and building links.
- BuzzSumo:
- Find out what is trending in your niche, and create content that engages.
- Moz and TubeBuddy:
- Moz is great for keyword research, while TubeBuddy is perfect for optimising YouTube content.
- Spotify for Creators and Linktree:
- Spotify for Creators (formerly Anchor) lets you create and publish podcasts, while Linktree helps you gather several links on one page, ideal for Instagram.
Want to read more?
Read also
- Search engine optimisation (SEO): the complete guide
- How search engines interpret the signals on your website
- Keyword research step by step
See all articles on SEO and AI search.
Need help with SEO? See my services or get in touch.
